Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming how businesses operate, with organizations increasingly relying on third-party AI vendors for automation, data analytics, and decision-making tools. These vendors provide a variety of AI-powered solutions, involving, for example, machine learning models, natural language processing, and computer vision tools which enable businesses to streamline processes, enhance efficiency, and improve data-driven decision-making.
Consider a customer service department using an AI-powered chatbot to handle consumer inquiries, a retailer using AI for supply chain optimization, or an online advertising platform leveraging third-party AI to optimize ad placements based on user behavior. These technologies offer significant efficiency benefits to the organization, but they also introduce privacy risks that organizations must carefully manage.
Privacy Risks Associated with AI Vendors
In many jurisdictions, privacy laws require organizations to ensure that their downstream contractors, including AI vendors, remain compliant with applicable data protection laws. Relying on third-party AI solutions does not absolve organizations of their legal responsibilities and those that fail to address these risks properly may face legal consequences, regulatory investigations, financial losses, or reputational damage.
The key privacy risks include:
1. Unauthorized Data Collection
AI vendors may collect more data than necessary, including sensitive personal information. This excessive data gathering can violate privacy regulations and expose organizations to compliance risks.
2. Data Misuse and Repurposing
Once data is shared with an AI vendor, there is a risk it may be repurposed—sometimes beyond the agreed terms, and in other cases, as part of the fine print. Vendors might use customer data to train AI models or sell insights to third parties, leading to ethical and legal concerns.
3. Lack of Transparency
Many vendors’ solutions involve “black box AI.” Businesses using their services have little insight into how data is processed, and face challenges in evaluating the integrity and security of the AI systems used. This lack of transparency can make it difficult to assess compliance with privacy laws.
4. Non-Compliance with Global Regulations
Many AI vendors operate across multiple jurisdictions, and failure to comply with local data protection laws can result in legal penalties for both the vendor and the contracting organization.
A well-known case highlighting AI vendor-related privacy risks involved Clearview AI, a facial recognition technology vendor. Clearview AI scraped various social media platforms for images to create a facial recognition database, which was employed by numerous law enforcement agencies worldwide, all without collecting requisite consent from the individuals whose photos it used. Regulators found that there was no lawful basis for the processing of this personal data, and as a result Clearview AI has faced considerable scrutiny and millions of Euros in fines. Organizations that employed Clearview AI’s facial recognition technology, too, face possible legal ramifications and reputational damage for engaging a vendor employing AI unethically and illegally.
It’s essential that organizations vet their AI vendors thoroughly, especially with the growing number of laws and regulations addressing both the specific use of AI in business, and data privacy practices more broadly.
Mitigating Data Privacy Risks
Managing AI vendors isn’t just about choosing the right technology—it’s about choosing vendors that handle data responsibly. To manage these risks effectively, organizations must understand which AI and data protection laws apply to them and implement vendor management best practices.
Key Regulations Relevant to AI Vendor Management
- General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) (Europe): Enforces strict guidelines on data collection, processing, and user consent. Organizations using AI vendors must ensure compliance to avoid heavy fines.
- Artificial Intelligence Act (EU AI Act): Establishes compliance requirements for AI systems, particularly those classified as high-risk. It mandates transparency, accountability, and data protection for AI vendors.
- California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) (United States): Authorizes the California Privacy Protection Agency to regulate the use of AI in California. A draft regulation to this effect is currently under review.
The legal landscape is continually evolving, with new AI and data protection regulations emerging worldwide. Organizations must understand how their geographic footprint, and the specific applications of their AI systems, could impact their regulatory obligations.
Best Practices for AI Vendor Management
1. Conduct Thorough Vendor Due Diligence
Before partnering with an AI vendor, evaluate their data protection policies, security measures, and overall compliance posture. Assess their regulatory compliance history and industry reputation.
2. Implement Data Processing Addenda
Establish clear contractual terms with AI vendors regarding data use, security, and compliance obligations. Include specific liability clauses to define accountability in the event of non-compliance.
3. Regularly Audit AI Vendors
Conduct periodic assessments of AI vendors’ data handling practices to ensure ongoing compliance with regulations and internal policies. Require vendors to provide transparency reports detailing their data processing activities and security measures.
4. Ensure Data Minimization
Limit the amount of data shared with AI vendors to only what is essential for the intended purpose. This enables lawful data processing and limits potential exposure in case of a data breach.
5. Leverage Privacy Enhancing Technologies
Where possible, implement encryption, pseudonymization, and other privacy enhancing technologies to enhance data security and protect sensitive information. Adopting these technologies helps mitigate risks associated with data breaches and unauthorized access.
6. Enable Continuous Monitoring and Risk Assessment
Ensure that AI vendors have monitoring mechanisms to detect unauthorized data access and require vendors to provide regular employee training on AI-related risks and data protection best practices.
Future Outlook on AI Vendor Management and Privacy
As AI adoption grows, regulations will continue evolving to address emerging risks. Organizations must stay ahead of these changes by adopting a proactive approach to AI vendor management. Governments worldwide are expected to introduce stricter compliance requirements, pushing vendors to demonstrate greater transparency and adherence to regulatory standards. At the same time, businesses will face growing pressure to partner with AI vendors that align with ethical AI principles, including fairness, accountability, and non-discrimination.
Actionable Recommendations
- Stay Informed of Regulatory Updates: Regularly review laws relating to AI and privacy to ensure compliance.
- Engage Data Privacy Experts: Work with privacy consultants to navigate complex regulations and implement strong vendor management policies.
- Vendor Assessment and Selection: Before engaging an AI vendor, conduct thorough due diligence to evaluate the vendor’s security protocols and compliance with relevant laws.
By taking these steps, organizations can effectively manage AI vendor risks, maintain regulatory compliance, and build consumer trust while using AI-powered services.
VeraSafe specializes in helping organizations navigate AI governance and data protection challenges, including vendor management. Whether you need support in conducting AI vendor due diligence, drafting compliant vendor agreements, or staying ahead of your organization’s regulatory obligations, VeraSafe can serve as your trusted partner at every step. Contact us today to learn how we can help you implement a responsible AI vendor management strategy.
Related topics: AI, Compliance Tools and Advice
You may also like:
AI Governance: Why It Matters and How to Implement It Internally
What Are the Privacy Concerns With AI?
An Introduction to the EU AI Act
